Back To Search Results
Previous Next

634 E First Street

Homes For Sale In
New Castle
Sylvan Estates
MLS® # 190611

$749,999

1 of 46 - 634 E First Street, New Castle, CO
2 of 46 - 634 E First Street, New Castle, CO
3 of 46 - 634 E First Street, New Castle, CO
4 of 46 - 634 E First Street, New Castle, CO
5 of 46 - 634 E First Street, New Castle, CO
6 of 46 - 634 E First Street, New Castle, CO
7 of 46 - 634 E First Street, New Castle, CO
8 of 46 - 634 E First Street, New Castle, CO
9 of 46 - 634 E First Street, New Castle, CO
10 of 46 - 634 E First Street, New Castle, CO
11 of 46 - 634 E First Street, New Castle, CO
12 of 46 - 634 E First Street, New Castle, CO
13 of 46 - 634 E First Street, New Castle, CO
14 of 46 - 634 E First Street, New Castle, CO
15 of 46 - 634 E First Street, New Castle, CO
16 of 46 - 634 E First Street, New Castle, CO
17 of 46 - 634 E First Street, New Castle, CO
18 of 46 - 634 E First Street, New Castle, CO
19 of 46 - 634 E First Street, New Castle, CO
20 of 46 - 634 E First Street, New Castle, CO
21 of 46 - 634 E First Street, New Castle, CO
22 of 46 - 634 E First Street, New Castle, CO
23 of 46 - 634 E First Street, New Castle, CO
24 of 46 - 634 E First Street, New Castle, CO
25 of 46 - 634 E First Street, New Castle, CO
26 of 46 - 634 E First Street, New Castle, CO
27 of 46 - 634 E First Street, New Castle, CO
28 of 46 - 634 E First Street, New Castle, CO
29 of 46 - 634 E First Street, New Castle, CO
30 of 46 - 634 E First Street, New Castle, CO
31 of 46 - 634 E First Street, New Castle, CO
32 of 46 - 634 E First Street, New Castle, CO
33 of 46 - 634 E First Street, New Castle, CO
34 of 46 - 634 E First Street, New Castle, CO
35 of 46 - 634 E First Street, New Castle, CO
36 of 46 - 634 E First Street, New Castle, CO
37 of 46 - 634 E First Street, New Castle, CO
38 of 46 - 634 E First Street, New Castle, CO
39 of 46 - 634 E First Street, New Castle, CO
40 of 46 - 634 E First Street, New Castle, CO
41 of 46 - 634 E First Street, New Castle, CO
42 of 46 - 634 E First Street, New Castle, CO
43 of 46 - 634 E First Street, New Castle, CO
44 of 46 - 634 E First Street, New Castle, CO
45 of 46 - 634 E First Street, New Castle, CO
46 of 46 - 634 E First Street, New Castle, CO
Save the listing See All 46 Photos
$749,999 Price
$190.65 Price Per Sqft
5 Beds
3 Baths
3,934 Square feet
1999 Year Built
No Pool
0.23 Acres

About 634 E First Street

Accepting Backup Offers! Tucked in a quiet neighborhood in the heart of New Castle! This spacious home offers nearly 4,000 sqft with 5 bedrooms, 3 bathrooms, vaulted ceilings, and a two-car garage. The entire home has been freshly painted and features a brand-new roof. The large walkout basement provides recreation and guest potential, and with no HOA, you'll enjoy true flexibility--an incredible value combining space, freedom, and location all in one!

Price Change History

Date: Details: Status Changed from Active to Active Under Contract –
Date: Details: Price Reduced from $774,000 to $749,999 Change: ↓ $24,001 (3.10%)
Date: Details: Price Reduced from $799,899 to $774,000 Change: ↓ $25,899 (3.24%)
Date: Details: Price Reduced from $839,000 to $799,899 Change: ↓ $39,101 (4.66%)
Date: Details: Price Reduced from $868,000 to $839,000 Change: ↓ $29,000 (3.34%)

Features of 634 E First Street

MLS® # 190611
Price $749,999
Bedrooms 5
Bathrooms 3
Full Baths 3
Square Footage 3,934
Acres 0.23
Year Built 1999
Type Residential
Sub-Type Single Family Residence
Status Active Under Contract

Community Information

Address 634 E First Street
Major Area New Castle
Area 10-New Castle Proper
Subdivision Sylvan Estates
City New Castle
County Garfield
State CO
Zip Code 81647

Amenities

# of Garages 1

Interior

Heating Natural Gas, Forced Air
Cooling Central Air
Fireplace No
Fireplaces Gas
Has Basement Yes
Basement Finished, Walk-Out Access
Living Heated Sqft 3,934

Exterior

Lot Description Cul-De-Sac
Roof Composition
Construction Wood Siding, Frame

Additional Information

Date Listed October 26th, 2025
Zoning Residential
Short Sale No
RE / Bank Owned No
Data Source AGSMLS
Short Termable No

Subdivision Statistics

Active Listings 2 Average Price $814,500 Average $/SF $220 Median $/SF $749 Listing Price $749,999

Listing Map

Request a Showing

Provide a valid email address.
When would you like to view this property?